The planets in our solar system come in two forms: Some are rocky, and some are gaseous. But all of the moons in our solar system are rocky, even the ones that orbit gas giants. So why aren’t some moons in the solar system made of gas? And are there gaseous moons anywhere in the universe?
There are some very good reasons why no nearby moons are gaseous. And while we haven’t found a gaseous moon beyond ourÂ solar system, it could be possible under the right conditions, said Jonathan Lunine, chair of the Department of Astronomy at Cornell University.
To illustrate how these conditions might affect a gaseous moon, imagine that our own moon’s rocky composition were replaced with pureÂ hydrogen. Hydrogen gas is much less dense than rock, so right away, theÂ moonÂ would grow to about the size ofÂ Earth, Lunine said.
In fact, the enormous size of gas giants like Jupiter is one reason they can exist. If they were too small, the force ofÂ gravityÂ wouldn’t be powerful enough to hold those light elements together.Â
But size isn’t the only factor at play; there’s also temperature.Â
“Let’s take the moon as it is â€” as a rock,” Lunine told Live Science. “And then let’s put a hydrogen atmosphere around it. We know that hydrogen atmosphere is going to escape very quickly just due to thermal effects.” In other words, the warmth of the sun would cause the hydrogen to evaporate away.
“And so what that would tell me is, an entirely hydrogen-composed Earth’s moon at the distance of the Earth from the sun is not going to be stable,” Lunine said. That’s true even as far out as Pluto’s orbit, he added.
But even if our imaginary gas moon were the size of Earth and the surrounding temperature were very cold, its host planet would still probably rip it apart.Â
“Remember that the Earth’s moon is subject to tidal forces from the Earth,” Lunine said. “So it’s actually not a sphere. It’s pulled out a bit, but it doesn’t get torn apart because it has some material strength associated with it.”
That’s not the case with the hypothetical gaseous moon. “Because it’s a gas and not a solid â€” even if it’s very cold â€” if it’s orbiting around something else, it’s going to get tidally stripped and torn apart by tides,” Lunine said.
So how could a gaseous moon ever be possible? The moon-planet system would have to be either very distant and cold, or very big.Â
“If it’s the size of our moon, anywhere in our solar system, it’s not going to work right. Way out in the depths of interstellar space? There, it’s a question mark,” Lunine said. “If you want to make something super big, like a Neptune around a Jupiter, then sure, you can do it.â€
In that case, the gravitational forces holding these huge bodies together would likely keep tidal forces from destroying the Neptune-size moon.Â
“That could be perfectly stable,” Lunine said.
Originally published on Live Science.