HomeHealthArtificial Intelligence and superficial knowledge

Artificial Intelligence and superficial knowledge

You may have heard of the new Artificial Intelligence application ChatGPT which can produce writing based on a simple instruction. It is intelligent, in other words. Artificially. That is, it is artificial in that humans aren’t doing the thinking.

The chatbot – launched last November – recently passed the US Medical Licensing exam – it achieved over 50 per cent in one of the hardest standardized tests in the world. To say that it has profound implications for human life – let alone medicine – is almost understating it.

We’ve had leaps in technology before. The mobile phone changed everything. Now we look at a movie based in the 1990s and wonder why the person stranded in a strange town doesn’t just pull out their mobile phone and google their location. There are things that happened in our recent past that will never happen again.

But let’s get back to ChatGPT – which as we have seen, is able to pass medical exams. We’ve had a little bit of plagiarism in third-level colleges for decades – indeed, many of the most intelligent and innovative people I have ever met cheated on their University’s exams. It’s almost a badge of pride to them that they could thwart the system.

But this is third level cheating potential on a whole other level. We simply can’t take the word of graduates in the future when we have no experience of their work. And we have had this experience in the Irish health sector before on several occasions.

There was the case of the doctor working in the University Maternity Hospital in Limerick two years ago who wasn’t able to take blood samples and who knew ‘near nothing’ about medicine. And we regularly report on doctors – mainly coming from abroad – whose qualifications have been questionable, and their ability to do their jobs is in serious question.

ChatGPT will change this dynamic because now, every punter that can work a computer will be able to pass exams, tests, essays and project work – all with the help of artificial intelligence and with their own superficial knowledge of the subject.

This will profoundly change medicine. Imagine I ask a leading Irish hospital consultant to write a piece for me on, say, the most recent updates on treatments for diabetes. In the past, that work might have done by the consultant herself, or passed down the line to a more junior doctor to write, and then checked by the main woman. In future, she’ll just ChatGPT it. It’s just too easy.

But eventually, and maybe sooner than expected, we’ll stop running those articles because they will contain nothing new, and nothing of value. Writing, and the business of writing, is not just about words and paragraphs and spelling things correctly. It’s the art of human communication on paper. Or papyrus, back in the day. Computer screens now.

Often, when I’m asked about what I do, I say I am a writer. I write articles, songs, stories, poems etc. They say: “Oh, I write too.” Which is like saying “I also talk, so I am also a ‘public speaker’.

I mean I am a writer who makes a living by being paid to write. It’s like being a musician – everyone has a bit of music in them – only a few can live off that talent. But what if my writing can be replicated? It would be foolish to think I am any more original than anyone else.

When I studied journalism in Canada, we were once assigned by our English teacher to write pieces in the style of another famous writer – a Steinbeck or a Hunter S. Thompson (We were just about at Borris at the edge of the Bog of Allen when the drink began to take hold). How clever we thought we were. But now that work is simple, replicable, and could be achieved by anyone with a computer or even a phone. Am I now worthless?

But my worries about my potential redundancy are nothing compared to the potential for medical fraud and impersonation. You simply cannot believe a person’s exam results any more – especially if they come from a country with which you have only tenuous connections. We could be looking at hundreds of Nigerian Princes who decide to quit the monarchy in order to practice (and it would be the other meaning of the word in this case) their medicine on patients in Ireland. Why not? The HSE are crying out for staff. Will they employ chatbots who have nothing to recommend them except an ability to use an app?

We have six medical schools in this country, and we are producing the finest doctors Australia can buy. We are supplying the facilities, the money, the infrastructure, the training, the teachers and the expertise so that Australians have the best doctors available.

That’s just not sustainable. Not when ChatGPT makes a mockery of entry exams of all kinds. They used to say that a verbal contract isn’t worth the paper it’s written on. Well, now a written exam isn’t worthy of the smallest degree of merit. In the same way that the mobile phone made the pub quiz obsolete, ChatGPT signals the end of written exams – though initially it will only apply to project work, theses, essays and almost all written work. Miniaturization will eventually take written exams down the same road.

It’s not all bad. Doctors may need to be assessed in person and in action. We may place a lot less faith in qualifications that are merely pieces of paper, and only value that and those which we know.
At the end of the day, we can’t be putting huge sums of money into training doctors for other countries. Not when we may end up with fakes while exporting the real thing. It was always an anomaly. Now it’s a massive joke. And here’s another.

We have one article in the February edition of Irish Medical Times that was written by ChatGPT. Or not. As they used to say in the recent but distant past – answers on a postcard please?

Source link


Discover more from PressNewsAgency

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

- Advertisment -