HomeHealthMedia Medics Manage Mendacity

Media Medics Manage Mendacity

We have all been a little amused at the way in which medics have become media stars in a relatively short period of time.

You can hardly turn on the radio or television without encountering a doctor or a ‘wanna-be’ epidemiologist being asked for their thoughtful views on pandemics, vaccines, pub opening hours, the long-term future of humanity, the Irish government’s response, the Delta variant, Boris Johnson and Matt Hancock, and the question that keeps insomniac dyslexics up all night – “Is there a dog?”

In the First World we have become used to medicine having the answers. We have become so used to it that we have significant numbers who take it so much for granted, that they can’t quite believe it. A man on BBC’s Newsnight was able to confidently aver that he distrusted the vaccine ‘because it had been developed so quickly’. He is one of the small but important subset of people who do not trust vaccination as the major weapon in this battle against Covid-19.

The great scientist Charles Darwin said that ‘ignorance more frequently begets confidence than does knowledge’ and while we may reflect that there are still individuals out there (including the recently departed leader of the Democratic Unionist Party, Edwin Poots) who believe the world is only a few thousand years old, there are others who believe much more harmful notions, and they genuinely have the capacity to cause misery and suffering.

The Dunning-Kruger effect is a type of cognitive bias in which people believe that they are smarter, more intelligent and more insightful than they really are. Essentially, people of low ability (or stupid people, as they were once known) lack the ability to recognize their own incompetence. And this combination of poor self-awareness and, ahem, low ability, leads them to overestimate their own abilities. Sweet, sweet irony.

‘Stupid’ is a little unfair. We are all products of our backgrounds, our education, the effort and care put into us as children and adults, our environment, our educational opportunities, our companions and colleagues and many, many other factors. There are thousands of people who believe all kinds of idiotic rubbish, which to them is perfectly reasonable, completely scientific (I saw it on FACEBOOK!) or the Word of God. Who is to say that someone else’s ‘idiotic rubbish’ is, in fact, ‘rubbish?

The obvious answer to that question is that not alone must scientists always argue for scientific theory and the proper presentation of knowledge, it is the hill on which their whole identity stands.

You can’t be a scientist and refute any part of basic science, or any awkward scientific fact. As much as it is the job of a scientist to understand how the world works, it is also their duty to explain to others not just the facts, but how the facts must be constituted, established and agreed. The scientific method is as important in this context as the actual facts, because it is within this context – and this context alone – that facts can be established as true.

And in the areas of disease and the human body, doctors are the scientists. They have an obligation not only to heal, but to explain the hurt. Doctors have two tasks when they encounter a patient – to not only cure the disease if they can; but also, to explain what is going on. It would be poor medicine to cure a person of an illness and not to explain why it happened, or to find a scientific reason for its occurrence. And ultimately, to add to the total store of knowledge about this disease, and how to deal with it.

The medical community has had to fight a battle for years against Big Tobacco, Big Alcohol, Big Gambling and all the other vested interests that wish to prioritise the acquisition of money over the public’s health. It was a fair fight in the sense that nobody was kidding anyone else on the evidence. The tobacco industry knew their product was a killer for decades – they just didn’t care about that fact compared to the potential money to be made in creating tobacco addicts. They would lie about it, but everyone knew they were lying. Doctors knew for certain, but the public also guessed that the tobacco lobby was mendacious and duplicitous.

The alcohol industry today does much the same thing – denying any problems and claiming that ‘everyone likes a drink now and then’ when in fact 77% of all alcohol* is sold to ‘problem drinkers’ or people who are drinking excessively. Without drinking problems, there is no alcohol industry. And the alcohol industry know that.

But we expect these lies. We know the motivation behind them. Money. What we don’t expect is the Spanish Inquisition. Sorry! What we don’t expect is that people without that financial incentive would lie for reasons which are more rightly accredited to the Dunning-Kruger effect.

And whilst we can effectively counter the tobacco and alcohol industries by pointing out their dishonesty, we are not going to convert anyone by calling them ‘stupid’. It presents a real problem for the doctors appearing in the media because it contrasts their two important but contradictory roles.

The public health doctor, the media doctor is meant to call out the stupidity and ridicule it. The actual doctor does not judge the patient but instead tries to help them. This is important in every instance, because people believe the images they get from television and radio – they may believe that a doctor ridiculing, say, hydroxychloroquine as a cure for Covid-19, may also ridicule them. They may extend this to the whole medical profession. And no-one wants to discourage sick people from visiting their doctor.

So, it’s a tricky balance for the media doctors – representing not just themselves whenever they speak, but the whole medical profession, whether they like it or not.

Apparently, Andrew Wakefield is now dating Elle MacPherson and they intend to get married soon.

Again, I just wonder how he sleeps at night. And if Elle is of any help.

* https://www.recoveryanswers.org/research-post/alcohol-sales-excessive-drinking/

Source link


Discover more from PressNewsAgency

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

- Advertisment -