Nearly nine months after taking office, Prime Minister Balendra Shah is embarking on his first bilateral visit to India on November 22-23. The visit is an opportunity to define the kind of relationship he wants with Nepal’s southern neighbour, identify shared interests and address longstanding differences. With his unconventional rise to power and limited political baggage, Shah has a chance to give Nepal-India relations a fresh direction. But that will require political courage to put Nepal’s interests firmly on the table.
Signing agreements and memorandums of understanding on development projects, or inaugurating completed projects, are routine features of high-level visits. They may signal cooperation but rarely deliver major breakthroughs. Instead of settling for piecemeal assistance, Nepal should push for broader economic cooperation, particularly to address its growing trade deficit with India, its largest trading partner.
Reducing the trade imbalance is essential to strengthening Nepal’s economic and, consequently, political standing. Attracting Indian investment should be a priority, as it could also encourage investors from third countries. Shah must make a strong pitch to Indian businesses. His address to Nepali and Indian industrialists during the visit provides an ideal platform.
Nepali exports, particularly tea, ginger and large cardamom, continue to face non-tariff barriers in India, hurting farmers and traders. Shah must press for their removal and seek a reliable mechanism acceptable to both sides. India should recognise certifications issued by Nepal’s quality assurance agencies. If concerns persist over laboratory standards, the two countries should work together to strengthen existing facilities or establish mutually recognised ones. Nepali products cannot continue facing arbitrary obstacles in their largest export market.
Border disputes also demand attention. The disagreements over Susta and Kalapani-Lipulekh-Limpiyadhura remain unresolved, with Indian security forces stationed in the latter region. Nepal’s historical treaties, maps and documents underpin its territorial claims. These disputes may not be settled during one visit, but they must be raised at the highest political level. Shah must make clear that Nepal will not abandon its claims or allow these issues to disappear from the bilateral agenda.
The Eminent Persons Group (EPG) report, prepared in 2018 to recommend ways of resolving longstanding bilateral issues, remains in limbo because the Indian prime minister has yet to receive it. Shah should press for its formal submission and seek an official Indian position. Implementation can be discussed later, but keeping the report under wraps indefinitely is unacceptable.
Air connectivity is another pressing concern. Nepal has long sought additional air entry routes through India following the construction of international airports in Bhairahawa and Pokhara. India’s reluctance has constrained their commercial viability. There is an opportunity to make progress on Nepal’s demands for entry points through Mahendranagar and Bhairahawa. Since India also has interests in Nepal’s airspace, both sides should pursue an arrangement that serves their mutual interests.
Electricity trade must feature prominently. Nepal needs a predictable framework that prevents periodic disruptions to cross-border power trade. India should also reconsider restrictions on purchasing electricity from projects developed by companies from third countries. Meanwhile, Indian companies have been awarded seven major hydropower projects with a combined capacity of around 4,700 megawatts, but only one is under construction. The practice of holding projects without making progress must end.
Pancheshwar remains another unfinished agenda under the Mahakali Treaty. Disagreements over water sharing and the distribution of costs and benefits have stalled agreement on the detailed project report. This requires political direction, not another round of bureaucratic discussions. Shah must push for a clear commitment to resolve the differences.
Nepal and India share deep political, social, cultural and religious ties, but longstanding disputes and mutual mistrust continue to undermine the relationship. Diplomatic engagement is the only way forward.
Discover more from PressNewsAgency
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.