The head of the nation’s peak Jewish body has condemned Labor for removing a call for listed terror group Hamas to disarm from its draft policy platform despite Prime Minister Anthony Albanese making the stance a core plank of his Middle East policy.
Labor planned to present a unified front on the contentious issue by having two Labor MPs from Melbourne – Josh Burns, who is Jewish, and Bassem Abdo, the son of Palestinian refugees – jointly present the section of the platform on Israel/Palestine in Adelaide on Saturday, the last day of the party’s national conference.
But infighting over wording of the manifesto, which was recently amended to be tougher on Israel and less demanding of the Palestinian side, threatens to derail hopes for an uplifting moment.
Executive Council of Australian Jewry co-chief executive Peter Wertheim, a longtime confidant of Albanese, said the draft platform lacked balance and failed to reflect the government’s stated policy positions.
“Instead of providing an honest assessment of the leadership on both sides of the conflict, the draft platform regurgitates the same old one-eyed obsession with blaming Israel,” Wertheim said in the Jewish peak body’s first comments on the draft platform.
“It is a reasonable question to ask why the ALP national conference is not backing in the Albanese government in expressly recognising the government’s position on excluding Hamas and requiring the Palestinian Authority to honour the commitments for governance reform upon which the government’s recognition of a Palestinian state was explicitly based.”
Wertheim said Albanese and Foreign Minister Penny Wong had repeatedly argued there must be no role for Hamas in Gaza, raising questions about why wording reflecting this stance had been expunged from the draft platform.
“Even Hamas itself has acknowledged it, by announcing a hand-over of its government functions to a US-backed technocratic committee,” Wertheim told this masthead.
“But apparently the ALP National Conference cannot quite bring itself to acknowledge it. The best it can do is refer to Hamas, in passing, as a terrorist group.”
Wertheim said the platform also failed to reflect the government’s insistence that recognition of Palestinian statehood relied on commitments from the Palestinian Authority, which governs parts of the West Bank, to reform its governance, terminate payments to the families of Palestinian prisoners, institute schooling reform, and hold general elections.
“The draft platform says nothing about any of this, or the fact that there has not been the slightest progress towards fulfilling the commitments made by the Palestinian Authority to the Australian government,” he said.
Wertheim and Albanese formed a bond two decades ago when Albanese opposed the boycott, divestment and sanctions movement against Israel, and Albanese regularly consults Wertheim on matters related to the Jewish community.
Albanese told the United Nations General Assembly last September that “the terrorist organisation Hamas can have no role in Palestine’s future”, adding Australia’s recognition of a Palestinian state was predicated on a set of commitments from the Palestinian Authority, including that “Hamas would hand over its weapons to Palestinian security forces – and never control Gaza again”.
When announcing $25 million in new aid funding for Palestine on Tuesday, Foreign Minister Penny Wong said: “This package demonstrates Australia’s practical commitment to Palestinian recovery, reform and institution-building. Hamas can play no role in the State of Palestine.”
Several Labor sources said former cabinet minister Ed Husic, a fierce critic of Israel’s conduct in the war in Gaza, had been pushing internally for the platform to go further in its criticisms of Israel.
Husic did not respond to requests for comment.
The latest version of the draft platform condemns the use of violence, including by Hamas, but earlier versions included an explicit reference that “Hamas must disarm and can have no role in the State of Palestine”.
An earlier draft also said that Labor “will continue to work with the international community to hold the Palestinian Authority to its commitments and to encourage normalised relations between Israel and its neighbours”. This wording was also removed from the latest version.
The draft version calls out Israel for settler violence in the West Bank, condemns a controversial new death penalty law and backs two international courts considering genocide and war crimes charges against Israel.
The Israeli embassy in Canberra said in a lengthy statement issued on Monday that it “respectfully submits that several elements of the draft national platform risk placing responsibility for the conflict on one party while giving insufficient attention to the decisions, conduct and continuing obligations of the Palestinian leadership and terrorist organisations such as Hamas”.
The Palestinian delegation in Canberra welcomed the draft platform and called for the government to go further by giving practical effect to last year’s decision to recognise Palestinian statehood.
Cut through the noise of federal politics with news, views and expert analysis. Subscribers can sign up to our weekly Inside Politics newsletter.
Matthew Knott is the foreign affairs and national security correspondent for The Sydney Morning Herald and The Age.Connect via X, Facebook or email.
Paul Sakkal is Chief Political Correspondent. He previously covered Victorian politics and won a Walkley award and the 2025 Press Gallery Journalist of the Year. Contact him securely on Signal @paulsakkal.14.Connect via X or email.From our partners
Discover more from PressNewsAgency
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.