College dream fulfilled for student lost to COVID

College dream fulfilled for student lost to COVID

       

Source link

FM Qureshi discusses COVID-19, Kashmir issue with Russian counterpart

0


Foreign Minister Shah Mehmood Qureshi   discussed with his Russian countepart Sergey Lavrov a range of issues including the COVID-19 pandemic and its ramifications on the region’s countries, and the ongoing brutalities by Indian occupation forces in Kashmir.

“Matters of mutual interest, including the COVID-19 pandemic, cooperation at the multilateral fora, prospects of enhanced bilateral cooperation, and regional issues were discussed by both ministers,” read a press release issued by theForeign Office (FO).

Reiterating that Pakistan considered Russia as an important partner and desired to forge a long-term and multi-dimensional partnership with the country, Qureshi offered condolences on the loss of precious lives in Russia due to the on-going global pandemic.

In response, Foreign Minister Lavrov also expressed solidarity with Pakistan in its efforts to combat the outbreak.

During an exchange of views on the socio-economic implications of the virus, Qureshi apprised Lavrov of Prime Minister Imran Khan’s call for debt relief for developing countries.

“Coordinated and comprehensive actions were essential to create fiscal space needed by the developing world to deal with the socio-economic impacts of Covid-19,” he said.

Shedding light on the current situation in India-occupied Kashmir, Qureshi communicated deep concern over the continuing double lockdown as well as the intensification of military crackdown by Indian occupation forces and attempts to change the demographic structure of the occupied territory.

“Urgent steps are required to address the grave situation,” the minister underlined.

Reaffirming Pakistan’s support for an Afghan-led and Afghan-owned peace process, Qureshi stressed the importance of inclusive intra-Afghan negotiations as the only way to build durable peace and security in the country.

According to the statement: “The two Foreign Ministers agreed on maintaining close consultations as part of regional efforts to support the Afghan peace process.”

Source link

Will Israel learn from its past leaders when it comes to annexation?

Jun 18, 2020

As Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s proposed date for annexing parts of the West Bank quickly approaches, there has been talk of Israeli leaders trying to meet with Jordanian officials to discuss moving forward with any decision. Yet increasing evidence indicates Amman may reject any negotiations — whether the planned annexation is big or small.

Over the years, Israeli officials have noted that what they see when they are in power is much different than what they expected when they were in the opposition. To many, this explained Menachem Begin‘s agreement to make peace with Egypt and give up the Sinai Peninsula, and it was also used to explain Ariel Sharon’s reversal on his position on Gaza settlements — which he had earlier said are the same as Tel Aviv, only to agree later to dismantle them and withdraw from the Gaza Strip.

Many proponents to the unilateral Israeli annexation are hoping that this would happen to the duo former chiefs of staff who are now respectively Defense Minister Benny Gantz and Foreign Minister Gabi Ashkenazi. People are perplexed on how best to accelerate the learning curve for them, especially for Ashkenazi who has been asked to lead the research by the Blue and White party in regard to the high cost of annexation.

The July 1 deadline set most likely in order to ensure that Israel can benefit from the presence of US President Donald Trump in the White House is proving to be way too short for this learning curve. Some have suggested that Ashkenazi, with or without Gantz, should visit the Jordanian capital and meet with King Abdullah and his team.

So far, according to the June 15 edition of the Saudi online news site Elaph, the request by the Blue and White party for an audience with the king has not been responded to. Jordanian sources told Al-Monitor that Jordan is unwilling to give indirect legitimacy to any annexation whether large or small.

Israeli media chatter has suggested that to avoid Jordanian anger, the annexation will begin with a small phase of some of the highly populated settlements that are stradling the old Green Line separating Israel from the 1967 occupied territories.

Jordan’s King Abdullah slammed that idea in his discussion with members of the US Congress. In a video conference call June 16 with a bipartisan group of members of Congress, the king warned that “any unilateral Israeli measure to annex lands in the West Bank is unacceptable and undermines the prospects of achieving peace and stability in the region.” The emphasis here was on “any” in order to cut off the Israeli possibility of thinking that they can get away with a smaller annexation.

Accepting the invitation shortly before the possibility of Israel deciding on annexation would be politically harmful to Jordan and would give an indirect indication of collusion, which Jordan doesn’t want to give. Al-Monitor has learned that in private meetings with journalists, Jordan’s Foreign Minister Ayman Safadi insisted that the kingdom has done everything it can to send a clear and unambiguous message of rejecting annexation in any form and on any land. A source in Israel told Al-Monitor that this is exactly the same message that Israel had received through a confidential channel it has with Amman.

With the idea of either large or small annexation being rejected by Jordan and most of the world, the Israelis appear to be searching for some kind of a reward to help Netanyahu climb down the tree that he had climbed, or the prime minister might choose to flip over the table and either go for broke and carry out the annexation or call for new elections. Polls show that his opponent’s party has receded in popularity while Netanyahu’s Likud continues to garner high polling percentage.

Daniel Kurtzer, former US ambassador to Cairo, Tel Aviv and Damascus and now a professor at Princeton University, wrote in the June 15 edition of the Cairo review, “Even if annexation does not take place, it will be imperative to avoid a sigh of relief and instead to resume the hard work against occupation and for the two-state solution.”

As has been the case in the past, it seems that the Israeli political establishment will not make a final decision until the very last moment. So far, Netanyahu appears to be holding all the cards very close to his chest and not even revealing the extent of the annexation, and even whether he will go through with it or not until the very last second, in the hope that he can extract the largest price in return for a delay or a retraction.

The move by Jordan to shut down the possibility of a smaller annexation will frustrate the argument of the Blue and White party, which wants any kind of a compromise that will be accepted — even grudgingly — by Arab neighbors and of course by Washington. The way things are moving show that such a compromise is unlikely and we will be faced with a last-minute decision — either the big annexation or none.



Source link

Jobless Claims Expected to Show Another Million Filings: Live Updates

0

The weekly tally of state jobless claims is again expected to exceed a million.

Businesses are reopening, but the layoffs won’t quit.

The Labor Department is expected to report on Thursday that 1.2 million people applied for state unemployment benefits last week. That would make it the 13th straight week that filings topped one million. Until the coronavirus crisis, the most in a single week was 695,000, in 1982.

Claims for Pandemic Unemployment Assistance, a federal program for self-employed workers, independent contractors and others ineligible for standard benefits, will add to the total.

“It’s a sustained hemorrhaging of jobs unlike anything we’ve seen,” said Heidi Shierholz, director of policy at the Economic Policy Institute, a progressive think tank.

Economists said recent layoffs, though smaller than the wave in March and early April, suggested that the crisis was reaching deeper into the economy.

Hilton Worldwide, the hotel operator, said this week that it was eliminating 2,100 corporate jobs globally and would extend previous furloughs and cuts in hours and wages for 90 days. AT&T disclosed plans to shed 3,400 technician and clerical jobs nationwide and to permanently close more than 250 stores, according to one of its unions. The gym chain 24 Hour Fitness said it was filing for bankruptcy protection and would permanently close more than 100 locations.

Wall Street is set for a lower open as stocks drift.

U.S. stock futures drifted and global markets were mixed on Thursday as investors awaited jobs data from the United States and more updates on new coronavirus outbreaks.

Futures markets were predicting a modest drop on Wall Street. European stocks traded in a narrow range in the morning, after Asian stocks drifted mildly lower.

Other markets also sent mixed signals. Prices for U.S. Treasury bonds fell modestly, and oil prices rose in futures markets, indicating some positive investor sentiment.

Investors were awaiting data on weekly jobless claims in the United States, which were expected to show that at least one million more people applied for unemployment benefits. They were also waiting the latest word on coronavirus infections in the United States, which have shifted to states like Arizona, Florida and Oklahoma. The number of infections also rose in Beijing, raising questions about China’s efforts to control the outbreak, which had been considered successful.

China plans a credit injection to jump-start its economy.

China aims to speed up an infusion of credit into its economy this year as it tries to restart growth after coronavirus the outbreak.

Speaking at the annual Lujiazui Forum in Shanghai on Thursday, Yi Gang, the governor of the People’s Bank of China, said that the authorities saw total social financing — a broad measure of credit in the Chinese economy — rising to more than 30 trillion renminbi, about $4.24 trillion, this year. That would be more than $600 billion above the 2019 level.

While the Chinese economy has rebounded by some measures since the lockdowns in the first part of the year, officials have acknowledged that joblessness remains a big problem.

Yet China’s moves show caution. In the United States, the Federal Reserve said in April that it would free up more than $2 trillion. Chinese officials have been wary about a big lending splurge after their response to the 2008 global financial crisis layered the economy with debt. Mr. Yi said officials would “moderate the total amount and consider the timely withdrawal of policy tools in advance.”

In another speech, Guo Shuqing, the chairman of the China Banking and Insurance Regulatory Commission, warned that the Fed played an unofficial role as the world’s central bank and would put the U.S. dollar and financial system at risk if it unleashed too much credit.

He warned that quickly rising stock markets might be harmful and unsustainable without real economic recovery. He did not specify the market, but global stocks have risen sharply from their earlier lows in part because many governments have rolled out big plans to spend money to get the economy humming again.

All countries and regions need to examine whether stimulus policies might be going too far, Mr. Guo said, noting the problems that can be created with too much credit. When stimulus efforts begin, “everyone rejoices,” he said. “When exiting, it may be very painful.”

Government relaxes loan forgiveness requirement that businesses rehire all workers.

Small-business owners won’t have to pay back their federal pandemic relief loans even if they don’t rehire all of the workers they laid off, the Trump administration affirmed, effectively eliminating a rule that many borrowers had feared would leave them stuck with a large debt.

The Treasury Department and the Small Business Administration, the program’s manager, released new loan forgiveness forms on Wednesday with a “safe harbor” option. Borrowers can simply affirm they were unable to operate “at the same level of business activity” they had before the crisis because of government requirements or safety guidance, including social distancing rules.

Those borrowers can have their loans fully forgiven if they meet the program’s other rules, including a requirement that they spend at least 60 percent of their aid money on payroll. The change follows a new law that loosened many terms of the Paycheck Protection Program loans.

For some leery borrowers, the recent changes were a major turnaround. George Evageliou, the founder of Urban Homecraft, a custom woodworking company in Brooklyn, had left his $192,000 loan untouched because he feared he would not be able to spend it in compliance with the program’s rules.

But the changes — in particular an expansion giving borrowers 24 weeks to spend their aid money — gave him time to safely restart operations and recall his laid-off employees. His staff began returning to work last week.

“We’re feeling pretty good about our decision to sit tight and let the law change,” Mr. Evageliou said. “We’re just so grateful for the help this grant will give us.”

Chanel says the collapse in travel will hurt its earnings.

Chanel said it expected a “significant” reduction in sales and profitability for 2020, the latest luxury business to warn on the serious hit to the sector caused by the coronavirus pandemic.

The storied French fashion house, owned by the secretive billionaire brothers Alain and Gerard Wertheimer, is one of the largest and most consistently successful luxury brands in the industry. On Thursday Chanel’s global chief financial officer, Philippe Blondiaux, said the company had reopened 85 percent of its global boutiques and recorded a “double or even triple digit recovery in sales” in markets like China and India.

But he noted, “That is local spending only, and simply put it will be insufficient when it comes to compensating the spending by traveling consumers.” The closure of duty free stores had also hit the company hard. “Even if airlines resume operations it will take a large proportion of 2020 and 2021 for things to get back to normal,” he added.

The disclosures came as it reported record annual results for 2019, the third time Chanel has disclosed earnings in its 110-year history. Last year, the company generated $12.3 billion in global sales, up 13 percent on a comparable basis year-over-year, with operating profit hitting nearly $4 billion, up almost 17 percent from 2019.

Despite a change at the creative helm — Virginie Viard succeeded Karl Lagerfeld, the longtime Chanel fashion director who died in February 2019 — Mr. Blondiaux said there had been double-digit growth in all regions and product lines for the fashion division last year.

A dispute over a $3.6 billion mall deal escalates.

Taubman Centers, the shopping mall owner that agreed to be acquired by Simon Property Group for $3.6 billion this year, is pushing back on Simon Property’s attempt to terminate the deal based on the pandemic.

Taubman, which owns 24 high-end malls including the Mall at Short Hills in New Jersey, said in court filings on Wednesday that Simon Property was experiencing “a classic case of buyer’s remorse,” and that the companies had “contracted to allocate the risk of global pandemics to the Simon parties, knowing full well that there was a pandemic raging in the world.” Taubman said that Simon Property had already negotiated a lower purchase price for the company based on an uncertain retail environment, that was shaky in part because of the coronavirus.

Simon Property, the biggest mall operator in the United States, said last week that the pandemic “had a uniquely material and disproportionate effect on Taubman” compared to other retail real estate companies, pointing to its high proportion of indoor malls versus open-air strip centers. It also faulted Taubman for failing to mitigate the impact of the pandemic by “not making essential cuts in operating expenses and capital expenditures.”

Taubman said on Wednesday that Simon Property’s comparison was flawed, noting that its malls were “hardly in the same industry” as strip centers, and that they did not have grocery stores or anchors like Home Depot or Target. The company also said that Simon Property was kept informed about its actions in response to the pandemic.

Hertz raised eyebrows last week when it asked for, and received, a bankruptcy judge’s permission to sell stock. It was an unusual move. Shareholders usually get wiped out during bankruptcy proceedings.

On Wednesday, Hertz reversed course on its plan to sell $500 million in shares, saying it had suspended further sale of its stock “pending further understanding of the nature and timing” of a review by the Securities and Exchange Commission.

Earlier in the day, Jay Clayton, the agency’s chairman, said on CNBC: “We have let the company know that we have comments on their disclosure,” and added: “In most cases, when you let a company know that the S.E.C. has comments on their disclosure, they do not go forward until those comments are resolved.”

It all seemed an unsurprising turn of events. In a prospectus on Monday, the company had warned that buying its stock was a risky move, and that investors who did should be prepared to end up losing money.

The S.E.C. declined to expand on Mr. Clayton’s statement, and Hertz did not respond to repeated requests for comment.

Hertz filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection from its creditors last month. The company, which started with a fleet of a dozen Ford Model T’s a century ago, had piled up $17 billion in debt and was unable to pay its lenders after the coronavirus pandemic grounded business travelers and tourists. A sharp drop in used car prices has also decreased the value of its fleet.

Catch up: Here’s what else is happening.

  • Kroger, the grocer with about 2,800 stores in 35 states, said Thursday that its sales increased to $42 billion in the quarter that ended May 23, up from $37 billion in the same period last year. Digital sales jumped 92 percent during the period marked by pandemic shutdowns. The company, which has about 500,000 employees, said it had hired 100,000 workers.

  • Carnival Corporation, the giant cruise company, reported Thursday that it lost $2.4 billion in the three months that ended on May 31. Carnival, which offered refunds or credits for future cruises to passengers whose voyages were canceled by the pandemic, said that about half asked for their money back. Customer demand for 2021 was increasing, it said, with about two-thirds of bookings in a recent six-week period coming fresh and one-third from customers using credits. Carnival said it could not say when it would return to normal operations.

  • Red Robin Gourmet Burgers, the casual dining chain that closed 35 restaurants and cut executive pay 20 percent in an effort to mitigate the effect of the coronavirus pandemic, said on Wednesday that it had raised $30 million through a stock offering. The company, based in Greenwood Village, Colo., said it planned to use the money for general purposes, including paying down debt. First-quarter revenue fell 25 percent to $306 million from the same period a year earlier, the company reported last week.

Reporting and research were contributed by Coral Yang, Sapna Maheshwari, Mohammed Hadi, Elizabeth Paton, Stacy Cowley, Jeff Sommer, Carlos Tejada, Ben Casselman, Tiffany Hsu and Gregory Schmidt.

Source link

NASA has built a helicopter to explore Mars and it’s finally ready to launch

0

NASA is ready to take its first spin at flying a helicopter on another world as the agency’s Mars helicopter, Ingenuity, prepares for launch in July.

The helicopter is part of NASA’s Mars 2020 mission, the star of which is the Perseverance rover, a robot designed to help scientists determine whether life on the Red Planet has ever been possible. Ingenuity isn’t a core tool for that objective, but it’s hitching a ride with the rover to test NASA’s ability to fly on another world.



Source link

Amazon ‘thwarts largest ever DDoS cyber-attack’

0

Image copyright
Getty Images

Image caption

Amazon Web Services is an enormous cloud-services provider and a major money-maker for Amazon

Amazon says its online cloud, which provides the infrastructure on which many websites rely, has fended off the largest DDoS attack in history.

Distributed denial of service (DDoS) attacks are designed to knock a website offline by flooding it with huge amounts of requests until it crashes.

Amazon Web Services (AWS) said the February attack had fired 2.3Tbps.

That is a little under half of all traffic BT sees on its entire UK network during a normal working day.

The previous record, set in 2018, was 1.7Tbps.

“This is huge news for people in the industry,” said Lisa Forte, from Red Goat Cyber Security, warning it was “enormous” compared with the previous all-time high.

“It is like comparing a moped to a super-car,” she said.

“They are totally different beasts.

“These are outliers.

“But as always with cyber-threats, we are in an arms race against attackers every day.

“This will definitely be an alarming revelation to many and could be a warning that we should not ignore.”

Media playback is unsupported on your device

Media captionExplained: What is a DDoS attack?

In a formal report about its DDoS protection service, AWS Shield, the company said the peak of the attack had been 44% larger than anything the service had seen before and resulted in a three-days of “elevated threat” status.

But it did not identify what website or online service had been targeted by the attack.

DDoS attacks are relatively simple in nature and rely on their sheer scale to be effective.

They often utilise large numbers of machines compromised by malware to launch attacks, which can be purchased online from cyber-criminals relatively cheaply.

They have been used by groups such as the hacktivist collective Anonymous to target the websites of companies or local governments they disagree with.

However, protection services such as AWS Shield, Cloudflare, and Akamai, among others, have been used by many major online services in an attempt to limit their effectiveness.

Source link

Covid-19: excess death rates more than twice UK average for 19 English councils

Nineteen local authorities in England have recorded excess death rates of more than twice the UK average during the Covid-19 crisis.

Local authorities in London have been hardest hit, with 16 of the 20 local authorities with the highest excess death rates located in the capital. Excess deaths in Harrow and Brent are three times that of the national average, at 64% and 63% respectively.

At its peak in the week to 17 April there were 138 deaths registered in Harrow, five times the average for the equivalent week in previous years.

Poorer boroughs including Newham and Haringey were also among the worst affected. Data from the ONS has previously shown that people living in the poorest parts of England and Wales were dying at twice the rate of those in the richest areas.

The death toll across the UK in the year to date shows that the excess death rate stands at 20.5%

Excess deaths are calculated by taking the total number of people whose deaths were registered in 2020 and comparing it with the average number of deaths in the five years prior. The difference represents the excess.

This measure is considered the gold standard when it comes to measuring the impact of the Covid-19 crisis as it accounts not just for people who have died directly as a result of coronavirus. For example, those who may not have sought or received treatment due to lockdown measures, deaths caused by a lack of basic care or nutrition and undiagnosed coronavirus deaths.

Graphic

The data also reveals that certain parts of Great Britain experienced higher death rates at different times. For example, Liverpool’s excess death rate peaked in the week ending 10 April but it would be another three weeks before Leeds experienced its peak.

Birmingham had more excess deaths than any other local authority for four weeks running , recording 415 excess deaths in the week to 17 April, almost two-and-a-half times the norm.

There is a strong correlation between high excess death rates and age. For example, the rural South Lakeland area’s excess death rate stands at 39%, almost twice the national average, and the area is one of the oldest in the UK when measured by median age.

Some parts of the country have remained relatively unscathed. In the south-west, Torbay, mid-Devon and east Devon experienced excess death rates within 2% of the norm as did Hastings and Eastbourne in the south-east and the Orkney Islands.

Na h-Eileanan Siar council area and the Shetland Islands did not experience any excess deaths while South Hams, Conwy in Wales, North East Lincolnshire, North Devon, South Hams and the Isles of Scilly have experienced fewer deaths this year than in previous years.

Epidemics of infectious diseases behave in different ways but the 1918 influenza pandemic that killed more than 50 million people is regarded as a key example of a pandemic that occurred in multiple waves, with the latter more severe than the first. It has been replicated – albeit more mildly – in subsequent flu pandemics.

How and why multiple-wave outbreaks occur, and how subsequent waves of infection can be prevented, has become a staple of epidemiological modelling studies and pandemic preparation, which have looked at everything from social behaviour and health policy to vaccination and the buildup of community immunity, also known as herd immunity.

Is there evidence of coronavirus coming back in a second wave?

This is being watched very carefully. Without a vaccine, and with no widespread immunity to the new disease, one alarm is being sounded by the experience of Singapore, which has seen a sudden resurgence in infections despite being lauded for its early handling of the outbreak.

Although Singapore instituted a strong contact tracing system for its general population, the disease re-emerged in cramped dormitory accommodation used by thousands of foreign workers with inadequate hygiene facilities and shared canteens.

Singapore’s experience, although very specific, has demonstrated the ability of the disease to come back strongly in places where people are in close proximity and its ability to exploit any weakness in public health regimes set up to counter it.

In June 2020, Beijing suffered from a new cluster of coronavirus cases which caused authorities to re-implement restrictions that CHina had previously been able to lift.

What are experts worried about?

Conventional wisdom among scientists suggests second waves of resistant infections occur after the capacity for treatment and isolation becomes exhausted. In this case the concern is that the social and political consensus supporting lockdowns is being overtaken by public frustration and the urgent need to reopen economies.

The threat declines when susceptibility of the population to the disease falls below a certain threshold or when widespread vaccination becomes available.

In general terms the ratio of susceptible and immune individuals in a population at the end of one wave determines the potential magnitude of a subsequent wave. The worry right now is that with a vaccine still many months away, and the real rate of infection only being guessed at, populations worldwide remain highly vulnerable to both resurgence and subsequent waves.

Peter Beaumont

All but one of the 50 worst-hit local authorities are in England, the exception being Inverclyde in Scotland where the total deaths in the year to date are 36.5% higher than in an average year, far higher than the Scottish average of 16%.

Previous analysis showed that people living in the most deprived areas of Scotland were more than twice as likely to die from Covid-19 as those living in the wealthiest parts. A large proportion (18.6%) of Inverclyde is made up of highly-deprived areas, and some of the most deprived parts of Scotland are found in Greenock and Port Glasgow.

Among the areas where excess deaths rates were above the UK average were East Dunbartonshire (26.7%), Edinburgh (24.3%) and Clackmannanshire (24%).

Three local authorities in Wales: Blaenau Gwent, where the excess death rate stands at 22.6%, Rhondda Cynon Taf and Newport, had an excess death rate above the UK average.

Northern Ireland does not produce data at a local authority level but excess deaths in the country are running at 10%, far below the UK average.

David Leon, professor of epidemiology at the London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, said the data showed how the overall impact of Covid-19 on mortality has varied across the UK.

“This epidemic has clearly had a serious impact on many local authorities that are not highly urbanised. Going forward understanding the reasons for this substantial geographic variation will be crucial in drawing lessons for the future for how to cope with any resurgence of Covid-19 or another pandemic.”

The three statistical agencies for the four nations: the Office for National Statistics (ONS) for England and Wales, the National Records of Scotland (NRS) and the Northern Ireland Statistics and Research Agency (NISRA), release their figures on different days. The figures run to week 24 for England and Wales and Scotland and week 22 in Northern Ireland.

Source link

Neptune’s weird moon Triton could get a visit from a NASA spacecraft called Trident

0

A possible new mission called Trident aims to explore Neptune‘s strange moon Triton. 

Neptune’s largest moon, Triton boasts an uncommon icy mixture on its surface, among other unique characteristics that could help scientists learn more about how bodies in the solar system evolved. Trident is one of four mission concepts competing in a current round of NASA’s Discovery program, which develops relatively low-cost robotic-exploration efforts. 



Source link

Vice President Pence congratulates history-making NASA astronauts in call to space station

0

A few weeks after watching NASA astronauts Bob Behnken and Doug Hurley depart Earth in historic fashion, Vice President Mike Pence checked in to see how the spaceflyers are adjusting to life in orbit.

Pence and his wife, Karen, were present at NASA’s Kennedy Space Center in Florida for the May 30 launch of SpaceX’s Demo-2 test flight, which sent Behnken and Hurley toward the International Space Station (ISS) aboard a Crew Dragon capsule. (President Donald Trump and his wife, Melania, made the trip to KSC for the occasion as well.)



Source link

Many Medical Decision Tools Disadvantage Black Patients

0

Unbeknown to most patients, their race is incorporated into numerous medical decision-making tools and formulas that doctors consult to decide treatment for a range of conditions and services, including heart disease, cancer and maternity care, according to a new paper published Wednesday in the New England Journal of Medicine.

The unintended result, the paper concludes, has been to direct medical resources away from black patients and to deny some black patients treatment options available to white patients.

The tools are often digital calculators on websites of medical organizations or — in the case of assessing kidney function — actually built into the tools commercial labs use to calculate normal values of blood tests. They assess risk and potential outcomes based on formulas derived from population studies and modeling that looked for variables associated with different outcomes.

“These tests are woven into the fabric of medicine,” said Dr. David Jones, the paper’s senior author, a Harvard historian who also teaches ethics to medical students.

“Despite mounting evidence that race is not a reliable proxy for genetic difference, the belief that it is has become embedded, sometimes insidiously, within medical practice,” he wrote.

The paper is being published at a tense moment in American society as black communities, disproportionately affected by the coronavirus, protest unequal treatment in other areas of their lives.

Dr. Jones said he believed the developers of the tools, who often are academic researchers, are motivated by empiricism, not racism. But the results, his analysis found, have often led to black patients being steered away from treatments or procedures that white patients received.

The paper included a chart listing nine areas of medicine where there are race-based tests, and it analyzed the consequences. For example, it reported, labs routinely use a kidney function calculator that adjusts filtration rates for black patients. With the adjustment, black patients end up with slightly better rates than whites, which can be enough to make those with borderline rates ineligible to be on a kidney transplant list.

An online osteoporosis risk calculator endorsed by the National Osteoporosis Foundation, among others, calculates chances of a fracture differently for black and white women. Black women end up having a score that makes them less likely to be prescribed osteoporosis medication than white women who are similar in other respects.

An obstetric calculator based on observational data concludes that black women who had a previous cesarean birth are less likely to have a successful vaginal birth in a subsequent pregnancy.

Dr. Jones added that it is time to stop what amounts to racial profiling in medicine. “We need to get off this train,” he said.

The New England Journal paper built on a collection of recent findings and assessments, including those in a recent paper about kidney function by Dr. Nwamaka Denise Eneanya and her colleagues at the University of Pennsylvania.

To determine how well kidneys are working, doctors use a blood test that measures a protein called creatinine to estimate kidney filtration rate. Low filtration rates indicate a kidney problem.

Dr. Eneanya’s team noted that patients with a filtration rate of less than 30 were referred to kidney specialists. They gave an example of a white patient whose level was 28, according to the calculator. A black patient with the same creatinine level would get a race correction under the formula that raises the level to 33. Consequently, the black patient would not get a referral to a specialist.

The same effect could make some black patients ineligible to be put on a list for a kidney transplant — those with filtration rates of 20 or above are ineligible.

The formula originated with data from a federal study more than two decades ago that asked if a low-protein diet reduced the risk of kidney disease (it did not, the study showed). The study included precise measures of kidney function and creatinine levels, which let researchers use creatinine to estimate kidney function. The formula fit the data best when they included an adjustment for black patients.

In a more recent paper, in 2009, the researchers combined data from a number of studies to devise an improved formula, asking which variables made the formula best fit the data. Race popped up again.

“The formula was widely adopted,” said Dr. Melanie Hoenig, a kidney specialist at Harvard Medical School.

One of its principal authors, Dr. Lesley Inker, a kidney specialist at Tufts Medical Center, said she hears the critics.

“What we say is, ‘You’re right. I understand the difficulty in assigning race,’” Dr. Inker said.

She is working on developing a more accurate formula that does not include race. She added that black patients should be told that their race alters the calculation and should be given an option to have their race excluded.

But, she says, the current formula also can be an advantage for black patients. Those with filtration rates below 30 are ineligible to be prescribed metformin, the first line drug for diabetes, and SGLT2 inhibitors, a more recent class of diabetes drugs.

One problem, is that it is not clear how race is determined. It shows up in medical records but, said Dr. Peter Reese, a kidney transplant specialist and epidemiologist at the University of Pennsylvania, “I worry that in some situations they look at you and assume.”

With the formulas, there is no accounting for people of mixed race, as the authors of the New England Journal paper and other doctors have noted.

Even if race does have a real affect on lab values for creatinine, why assume it is because of the genetics that determine skin color, some experts asked.

“It could be diet or any of a number of things,” Dr. Hoenig said, noting that a large protein-heavy meal can temporarily raise creatinine levels.

One often cited explanation is the belief that black people are more muscular than white people, and muscles can release creatinine into the blood. In a recent paper, Dr. Vanessa Grubbs, a kidney specialist at the University of California, San Francisco, tried to trace the origins of that belief and found only a few decades-old studies that did not even measure muscle mass directly, including one saying black children are thinner than white children.

A group of medical students at Harvard has been trying to change the approach to assessing kidney function, with some success.

The group, including Leo Eisenstein, Danika Barry and Cameron Nutt, had heard Dr. Jones in lectures saying race was a social construct and then went into the clinic, where they were told to use a formula that corrects for race in assessing kidney function.

Instead of complaining, Dr. Hoenig told the students, why not go to the leadership and suggest a change? Labs could simply not list race when sending in blood tests for creatinine — in that case the formula’s default would be the level for whites. Or they could give results as a range and explain to patients that the numbers are an estimate.

A few years ago, Dr. Hoenig and the students made the rounds to executives at Beth Israel Medical Center.

“We went to the chief of medicine, we went to the head of clinical labs, we went to the head of the kidney division, we went to a lot of people and spun our story,” she said. “They were open to it.”

In 2017, Beth Israel dropped the race factor in calculating kidney function. But despite pleas for a change, no other hospitals have followed suit.

Recently though, San Francisco General has replaced race as a factor with a choice of values for kidney function depending on the doctor’s assessment of whether the patient was muscular or not.

Advocates of change like Dr. Hoenig say they think part of the problem is resistance to changing a system that has become part of medicine.

Dr. Darshali A. Vyas of Massachusetts General Hospital, who is first author of the New England Journal paper, said the ultimate goal is for doctors and researchers to rethink the assumption that they can use a patient’s race in making medical decisions.

“This is a challenge to the field about how we think about race and what our default assumptions are about race,” she said.

Source link